Honest comparisons

Each page makes the other side's case properly first, names who should choose it, and only then says where removal wins. If a free Apple feature is enough for you, these pages say so.

Screen Time vs tinyphone →
Where Apple's built-in limits genuinely work, the three documented failure modes, and when removal beats rationing.

Assistive Access vs tinyphone →
The community's real complaint list (Wallet, voicemail, notifications), the off-switch problem, and when each one is right.

Light Phone vs tinyphone →
The honest case for the hardware, the two-phone outcome it often becomes, and which path fits which person.

The method-level view: the dumb-iphone guide · app-level: app by app.